Best Alternative to Mint Budget App: A 5-Point Checklist
Five checks to put to any Mint replacement, and how YNAB, Monarch, Copilot, Rocket Money and Tovari answer them.
The best alternative to Mint is the one that passes five checks: bank sync that works with your banks, a price you can live with every year, a budgeting method that fits how you budget, a way to bring in your old Mint history, and a privacy policy that doesn't sell your data. I'm the founder of Tovari Financial, so this isn't an independent review. I've put the same five checks to Tovari as to everyone else, and said where it falls short.
What did Mint users actually lose when the app shut down?
Intuit shut Mint down in March 2024 and pointed its users at Credit Karma. Three things went with it.
Free auto-tracking with bank sync
Mint connected your accounts and sorted your transactions at no cost. Every replacement either charges for bank sync or asks you to enter transactions by hand.
Your transaction history
Years of transactions, categories and trends were the real value. If you exported before the shutdown, you have the raw data. How much of your categorizing work survives depends on the app that reads it.
A zero-cost starting point
Mint cost nothing, which suited households living paycheck to paycheck. The serious replacements charge a subscription, a hard sell when the whole point is saving money. Mint was paid for another way: by recommending credit cards and loans. Our Mint alternative page goes into that.
Which five checks should decide your Mint alternative?
Put every app you try through these five, in this order. Each has its own section below, and the same list is applied to every app named here, ours included.
Bank sync
Connect your actual banks during the free trial before paying anything. An app that can't reach one of your banks needs a fallback for that account.
Yearly cost
A subscription that "pays for itself" is a hard sell when there's no slack in the month. Compare the yearly price, check what the trial asks for to start, and make sure you can cancel without a penalty.
Budgeting method
Mint mostly tracked what you'd already spent. If you want zero-based budgeting, or envelopes that roll over, check that the app does it natively rather than through workarounds.
Importing your Mint history
If you have a Mint export, check what the app does with it before you commit: whether it reads the file at all, and whether your categories come with it.
Privacy and data selling
Ask plainly: does the app sell or share your data, or show you ads? If the answer is buried in the policy, treat it as yes.
You'll find Tovari set beside each of these apps on our comparison pages, including where it falls short.
Which Mint alternatives can import your Mint history?
If you exported your Mint transactions before the shutdown, the file you have is a single CSV covering every account. Whether a replacement can read it decides whether you start with a blank slate or with years of history.
How each app handles a Mint export
| App | Reads your Mint export | Your Mint categories |
|---|---|---|
| Monarch Money | Yes, with a Mint-specific import | Brought across and matched to Monarch's |
| Copilot Money | Yes, with a Mint importer added in 2024 (iPhone and Mac) | Check Copilot's help pages for how they map |
| YNAB | Yes, as a CSV, one account at a time | Not carried over |
| Tovari | Yes, as a CSV, one account at a time | Not carried over; Tovari sorts transactions itself |
| Rocket Money | No file import | — |
Check each app's import help pages before you pay. Column mapping is where imports usually go wrong.
What a Mint file needs before Tovari can read it
Tovari's file import reads CSV, OFX and QFX, on the web on a PC or Mac. Each import goes into one account you choose, and nothing is written until you've reviewed it. Mint's export needs two changes in a spreadsheet first:
- Split the file by its Account Name column, so each account gets its own file.
- Mint lists every amount as positive, with a separate Transaction Type column saying debit or credit. Make the debit amounts negative, so spending comes in as money out.
- Import each file into its account, map the Date, Description and Amount columns, and review before you confirm.
Your Mint categories don't come with it. Tovari sorts each transaction itself, and anything it can't place waits in the Review Center for you. If keeping your Mint categories matters most, Monarch is the closer fit.
How do bank connections compare across Mint alternatives?
Bank sync is the first thing to test, because a budget built on transactions that never arrive is worse than none. YNAB, Monarch, Copilot, Rocket Money and Tovari all connect to banks through aggregators such as Plaid. When a connection drops, transactions stop arriving until it's fixed, and some of that fix sits with the aggregator or the bank rather than the app you pay for.
That matters most when there's no slack in the month. A missing paycheck or a double-counted bill makes any spending number wrong in the direction that hurts.
A fallback for when a connection fails
Whichever app you pick, make sure it has a way to keep going when a bank won't connect: a manual account you can type into, or a file you can download from your bank and import. Tovari has both. Manual accounts work just like connected ones, and you can reconcile any account against your statement, so a missed or doubled transaction shows up instead of staying wrong.
What does each Mint alternative cost per year?
Prices are often quoted monthly but billed yearly, so compare the yearly figure. These are the prices when we last checked, from our pricing page and comparison pages, and they change without notice:
| App | Price |
|---|---|
| Tovari | $5.99 a month or $44.99 a year |
| YNAB | $14.99 a month or $109 a year |
| Monarch Money | $14.99 a month or $99.99 a year |
| Copilot Money | $18 a month or $109 a year, iPhone and Mac only (no Android) |
| Rocket Money | Free tier; Premium $7 to $14 a month |
None of these charges a one-time fee. Most offer a free trial, so connect your banks and try the categorizing before you pay. Tovari's trial is 14 days and needs a card to start. Our Rocket Money comparison covers what its free tier does and doesn't include.
Which budgeting method does each Mint alternative use?
Mint mostly showed you what you'd already spent. None of the main replacements copies that exactly, so the method matters more than the price.
Envelopes and rollover
YNAB is zero-based budgeting: you give every dollar a job before you spend it, and what's left in a category carries into next month. Monarch offers budgets with rollover too. If you lived in Mint's category budgets without wanting to plan every dollar, zero-based is a step up in effort.
Tovari has envelope budgeting as well. Any spending category can be an envelope, rollover is set per envelope, and each category can carry a goal for the year. Nothing is turned into an envelope unless you choose it, so you can track most categories Mint-style and budget only the ones that need it. The budget docs explain how it works.
Safe to Spend: the number Mint didn't give you
Rocket Money leans on tracking and alerts, closest to Mint's hands-off style. Tovari adds a forward-looking number: Safe to Spend takes your included account balances, adds the income scheduled before your next paychecks, and subtracts the bills due in that window. Mint told you where the money went. This tells you what you can spend before the next paycheck lands.
How should you judge a Mint alternative's privacy?
Mint was free because it earned money by recommending credit cards and loans. Any free app has to make money somewhere, so find out where before you connect your bank.
What to check in the privacy policy
Check three things: whether the app sells or shares your data, whether it shows you ads or partner offers inside the product, and whether deleting your account deletes your data. An app that earns money on recommendations will show you credit cards and loans whether or not they fit your budget.
Questions to ask before connecting accounts
Who sees my transactions? Can I use the app without connecting my bank? Can I take all my data out when I leave? Entering transactions by hand keeps your bank login out of the app, though whatever you enter is still stored by the app you use. Tovari never sells your personal information and shows no ads; our privacy policy has the details.
What is the fastest way to switch from Mint to a new budgeting app?
If you have your Mint export
Keep a copy of the file somewhere safe. Check how your new app handles it (see the table above), and import it before you connect your banks, so you can see what overlaps.
If you never exported
The data is gone with Mint, but reconnecting your banks can still bring some history back. In Tovari, a new bank connection can bring in up to two years of past transactions, depending on how much your bank makes available. Many banks also let you download older statements as CSV, OFX or QFX files.
A weekend migration checklist
Saturday: gather your Mint export or bank downloads, list your recurring bills and their due dates, and note the categories you used. Sunday: connect your accounts one bank at a time, so a broken connection is easy to spot; import any files; and set up your bills. Monday: check that each account's balance matches your bank before you trust any spending number.
How does Tovari score against this same checklist?
Bank sync: Tovari connects US banks through Plaid, the same kind of connection the others use, so it has the same weakness when a bank's connection drops. Manual accounts, file import and statement reconciliation are there for when it does.
Yearly cost: $44.99 a year, or $5.99 a month. There's no free tier, and the 14-day trial needs a card to start.
Budgeting method: envelope budgeting with rollover set per envelope, plus a Safe to Spend number that looks ahead to your next paychecks.
Mint history: CSV, OFX and QFX import, one account at a time, on the web. There's no Mint-specific importer, so a Mint file needs splitting by account first, and your Mint categories don't come with it.
Privacy: no selling your personal information, no ads, and a full export of your data whenever you want it.
Where it falls short: it's a younger and smaller product than YNAB or Monarch, with fewer integrations. Its numbers are only as fresh as your last sync or entry. And if carrying your Mint categories across matters most, Monarch's Mint import does that and ours doesn't.
FAQ
Is there a truly free alternative to Mint?
Not one with the same mix Mint offered. The apps here either charge for bank sync or ask you to enter transactions by hand. Rocket Money has a free tier, with more in its paid Premium plan. EveryDollar and Goodbudget both have free plans if you enter transactions yourself. A spreadsheet is free too.
Do any Mint alternatives charge a one-time fee instead of a subscription?
None of the apps compared here does. YNAB, Monarch Money, Copilot Money and Tovari are subscriptions, and Rocket Money has a free tier with a paid Premium plan. If a subscription is out of the question, a spreadsheet or a free manual-entry plan avoids recurring charges.
Can I use a spreadsheet instead of a budget app after Mint closed?
Yes, and it works if you keep it simple. Open your Mint export, list your recurring bills with their due dates, and update your balances by hand. You give up automatic bank sync and automatic categorizing, so every transaction is typed in. In return, there's no subscription and nothing to connect.
Which Mint alternative works best for paycheck-to-paycheck budgeting?
The one that gives you a number you trust without a price that strains the month. Tovari's Safe to Spend works out what's left after the bills due before your next paychecks, and it costs $44.99 a year. YNAB fits if you want zero-based planning and its long-standing method. Whichever you try, connect your actual banks during the free trial before paying.
Will a new budget app keep my old Mint categories?
Mostly no. Monarch Money's Mint import is the one built to bring your Mint categories across. Copilot Money has a Mint importer too; check its help pages for how it maps categories. YNAB and Tovari read CSV files but don't carry over your Mint categories. Tovari sorts each transaction itself and asks you about the ones it can't place.